pirateshosting.net vs hostplay.com
 

Which server would you sign up with - pirateshosting.net or hostplay.com?
What would you do being in my place?

I have noticed Hostzealot.com is nice place to get dedi plans. Servers are affordable ans working perfectly. Support is skilled and responsive.

Have a look at servers from hostsailor.com and veeble.org.,
Servers have good performance and aren't overloaded.
Resources are known and not oversold.

Are they reputable host with high available support, featured plans and solid server solutions.

Taking into account your needs, I suppose Hostzealot.com would match the best dedicated server host for your needs. They will help you to compare various web hosts. Their service is totally worth it!